Tweeting is often compared to shouting into a gorge, a la the climactic scene in Garden State — a meaningless, but nonetheless cathartic act of self-expression.
But one of the glories of Twitter is you can tell powerful figures and institutions to suck your ass, and there’s a good chance that message will actually be received.
Those frustrations rarely reach the upper echelons of that institution, though, and are instead fielded by lowly, fresh-faced social media managers who have no real decision-making power. And those social media managers are sick and tired of being trolled everyday — especially in the realm of Sports Twitter.
The poor soul who runs the Twitter account for the Minnesota Timberwolves tweeted a plea to fans to please stop inundating the account with suggested trades ahead of the NBA’s Thursday trade deadline.
Fans, we appreciate your continued dedication to proposing trade after trade in our mentions…this may come as a surprise, but we’re just the Twitter account. We don't have control over these things.
— Timberwolves (@Timberwolves) February 6, 2018
The solidarity from other social media managers at other NBA franchises was more or less immediate:
RT RT RT
— Memphis Grizzlies (@memgrizz) February 6, 2018
PREACH!
— Atlanta Hawks (@ATLHawks) February 6, 2018
Even as an extremely casual sports fan, though, I can relate to the borderline psychotic behavior of diehards. The entire point of being a sports fans is forming a fake emotional connection to an organization you have no role in, and getting unreasonably happy and/or upset about their performance. (Academics might call this tribalism.)
I’ve tweeted at my hometown Chicago Bears exactly twice. The tweets occured six and a half years apart from each other, and both were about former Bears tight end Greg “Third Leg” Olsen.
Going to be truly sad if @gregolsen82 gets traded. Having only one member of the 7th floor crew on the Bears doesn't seem right.
— Johnny McDermott (@mcdermott) July 28, 2011
Remember when the Bears traded Greg Olsen for two dirty dish rags? Because I will never forget.
— Johnny McDermott (@mcdermott) January 7, 2018
I know why I sent those tweets — I’ve always had a love affair with cocky tight ends from the University of Miami (e.g., Jeremy Shockey and Kellen Winslow II), and was downright giddy when the Bears drafted Olsen, the latest person in that rich legacy at the time. So I was furious when the Bears traded him for effectively nothing.
But even then, I didn’t @ mention the team directly, meaning my complaints were essentially subtweets. I never anticipated the Bears actually responding to my angry fan missives, so mentioning them seemed unnecessary.
What about everyone else who does @ mention their favorite team, though? Do they really believe their message will have an effect on the front office’s decision-making?
38 MINS TO TRADE TRISTAN YALL DONT LET ME DOWN!!!!! @Cavs
— 12/29? (@Obey216) February 8, 2018
According to Cleveland Cavaliers fan @Obey216, yes, that’s exactly why fans tweet at their favorite teams — they want their voices heard and to influence personnel decisions, and what better venue for that feedback than Twitter.
Do you tweet at the Cavs often? And if yes, why?
— Johnny McDermott (@mcdermott) February 8, 2018
Yes, I feel like the things I say could possibly reach someone who could make something happen. The fans matter the most, our opinions and suggestions should be put into consideration.
— 12/29? (@Obey216) February 8, 2018
Yes, the consumers can always make a difference. The @Cavs knew the fans needed something different. They have to make sales and that's all based on the people. They really don't have a choice to be honest. We might not get everything but I'm sure it's considered.
— 12/29? (@Obey216) February 8, 2018
Others, such as Hawks fan @bill_cosby_drug (problematic username), have no such delusions.
We're contenders now
— Bill Cosby (90-72) (1-4) (@bill_cosby_drug) February 8, 2018
He just tweets to offer his humble support for the franchise.
I'd say it has about a 0% effect on anything. I just like to point out if someone had a good game or point out if I think one of our players has good potential. Stuff like that
— Bill Cosby (90-72) (1-4) (@bill_cosby_drug) February 8, 2018
Some fans have no explanation at all, proving both the gorge shouting, and “irrational fan who thinks he’s actually part of the organization” theories posited above.
Why tweet at teams at all? Do you think they're going to respond? Do you think they take into consideration when making decisions?
— Johnny McDermott (@mcdermott) February 8, 2018
https://twitter.com/PlayerPlayer24/status/961735060054528000
This doesn’t do much to refute the claim that sports fans are crazy idiots, but again, that’s a large part of the appeal of being a fan in the first place. You scream at the television. You engage in endless arguments about inherently unresolvable sports debates. You wear your team’s jersey.
And increasingly, you tweet at your favorite team about how they need to trade Tyreke Evans’ bum ass, or ship off Marc Gasol and start the rebuilding process already.
Dear @memgrizz executives, please trade Marc Gasol. Love the guy and all he has done for the team in the past but it’s time to move on and REBUILD. Grit n Grind is gone
— Drew Lyons (@DWL_9) February 8, 2018